Brownstone and townhouse roofing in Manhattan
- NYC license 2135523-DCWP
- Free estimates
- 24/7 leak calls
- Written warranty on new roofs
Short answer: We repair and replace roofs on Manhattan brownstones and townhouses, from Harlem and the Upper West Side to the Upper East Side, the Village and Chelsea. These roofs are small, flat and hard to reach, with a front parapet on the street, a hatch or bulkhead, often a skylight, and walls shared with the neighbors. We find where the water gets in, tell you plainly whether a repair will hold, and work through the house without wrecking it. Estimates are free.
How a brownstone roof is built
From the street a brownstone looks like it has no roof at all. Up top, almost all of them have the same parts:
- A flat or nearly flat roof, usually pitched slightly so water runs toward the back or to a drain.
- A front parapet and cornice facing the street. Some cornices have a gutter built into them, often called a Yankee gutter.
- Party walls on both sides, shared with the houses next door, often rising a little above the roof as low parapets.
- A hatch or a stair bulkhead to get up there, and often a skylight over the stairs.
- A rear edge with a gutter and leader, or a drain, and sometimes a lower rear extension roof.
- Layers. Many brownstone roofs have been roofed over two, three or more times over the last century.
Each of those joints is a place for water to get in. The front and back edges, the bulkhead and the skylight are where we look first.
Most Manhattan brownstone roofs are roughly 600 to 1,200 sq ft, plus any rear extension.
The brownstone roof problems we see
- A spongy roof. Layers on layers trap water between them. The roof feels soft underfoot and leaks somewhere new every year.
- Puddles that don’t go away. Old roofs sag, drains sit too high, and the slope to the back is gone. NYC’s code expects a roof to drain within 48 hours after rain.
- Leaks at the front wall or the back. Flashing at the parapet, the cornice or the rear gutter has cracked or pulled away.
- Bulkhead and hatch leaks. The door threshold and the bulkhead walls take wind-driven rain.
- Skylight leaks. Old curbs and flashing fail before the glass does.
- Party wall joints. Where your roof meets the neighbor’s, flashing laid by different roofers at different times often doesn’t overlap properly.
- Loose bricks or coping on the front parapet. Freeze-thaw opens the mortar. On the street side that’s a safety problem, not just a leak. See parapet and coping repair.
Our roof repair page explains how we find the source of a leak.
Repair or a new roof?
“We’ve had five roofers out and each has a different opinion” is something brownstone owners say a lot. Part of the answer is in the building code. A new roof can go over one existing roof only if it’s dry and sound; over a wet roof, or over two or more existing roofs, the old layers have to come off (section 1511.3.1.1 of the 2022 NYC Building Code). On many brownstones that settles it: the roof needs a full tear-off.
If the roof is one dry layer with a problem in one place, a repair usually makes sense. Our roof replacement page walks through a tear-off step by step.
We make a small test cut to count the layers and check the insulation, and show you the photos, so the decision is based on what’s actually there.
Parapets, party walls and your neighbors
On a row house your roof is joined to the neighbors’ roofs on both sides. That matters when something leaks or when one roof is replaced:
- A leak at a party wall can come from your side, their side, or the joint between them.
- When we replace your roof, the new flashing at the party wall has to tie in to the neighbor’s roof without damaging it.
- Work on a shared parapet usually needs the neighbor’s agreement, and sometimes access to their roof.
We tell you before the job if the neighbor needs to be involved, and we photograph their side before and after.
The front parapet is also covered by NYC’s yearly parapet observation rule when it faces the street. The rule exempts detached one- and two-family houses, but row houses are attached, so many brownstones aren’t exempt. Our roof inspection page explains what the yearly check involves.
Landmark districts
Many brownstone blocks in Harlem, the Upper West Side, the Upper East Side, the Village and Chelsea are in historic districts. Under the Landmarks Preservation Commission’s rules, replacing a flat roof, insulation included, doesn’t need a Landmarks permit. What’s visible from the street does get reviewed: flashing, gutters and leaders, decorative elements, and railings (LPC Rules §2-11). LPC also has a fact sheet on solar panels on landmarked buildings: keep them low, set back and hard to see from the street.
Our NYC roof permit guide covers DOB permits and other approvals.
Getting onto the roof without wrecking the house
On a brownstone, everything goes through the house or over the front: there’s no loading dock and rarely room for a crane.
- We reach the roof through the hatch or bulkhead and protect the stairs, banisters and top-floor rooms with covers on the way.
- Old roofing comes down in bags or by hoist, and a container on the street needs a city permit.
- On a tear-off we open only as much roof as we can close the same day.
Most brownstone roofs are done in days, not weeks; the estimate gives you the dates.
Skylights, cornices and gutters
- Skylights: if a skylight is old, replacing it at the same time as the roof saves cutting into the new roof later. We replace skylights as part of the roof job, and repair or replace them on their own too: see skylight repair.
- Cornices and built-in gutters: we check the cornice and any gutter built into it during every inspection, because water there shows up as stains on the front wall. We repair cornice flashing and reline built-in gutters as part of the roof work.
What it costs
A full new flat roof is typically $13 per sq ft, and a small leak repair is usually about $1,000, depending on the job. On a brownstone the price moves with how many old layers come off, wet insulation or deck repairs, parapet and party-wall flashing, skylights, and how material gets up and down. Our roof replacement cost guide explains prices in detail.
If you own and live in the house and your income is within its limits, HPD’s HomeFix program can help pay for roof repairs. Our roof repair page explains who qualifies.
At that rate, a 600 to 1,200 sq ft brownstone roof starts at about $7,800 to $15,600 before extras.
FAQ
Do I need Landmarks approval to work on a brownstone roof?
Replacing a flat roof, including insulation, doesn’t need a Landmarks Preservation Commission permit, even in a historic district. Work that can be seen from the street, like visible flashing, gutters, leaders, decorative elements or railings, is reviewed by LPC. Solar panels have their own LPC guidance.
What if the parapet is shared with my neighbor?
We look at both sides of the wall first and tell you if the neighbor needs to be involved. Work on a shared parapet is usually agreed with the neighbor beforehand, and often split between the two owners. When we replace your roof, we tie the new flashing into the neighbor’s roof without cutting into it, and photograph their side before and after.
How many days does a brownstone roof job take?
A repair is often done in a day. A full replacement on a typical brownstone usually takes days, not weeks, depending on the layers, deck repairs and weather; the estimate gives you the dates.
What roof system works best on a brownstone?
We usually recommend a two-ply modified bitumen roof on brownstones. It handles the many flashing details at parapets, bulkheads, skylights and chimneys well, and it stands up to foot traffic when you or a contractor need to go up.
Updated